Home
Introduction
What train set to buy
Cost
Basic Tools
Base Board
Railway Track
Kato Track
Track Conversion
Building a Layout
Layout Designs
Members Layouts
Electronics
Digital Control (DCC)
Electronic Projects
Scenery
Plastic Kits
Rolling Stock
Maintenance
Model Railway Spares
Service Sheets
Harry Potter
Thomas Tank Engine
7mm Narrow Gauge
Railway Software
Downloads
Photo Gallery
FAQ
Forums
Classified Ads
Railway Dictionary
Competitions
Links / Sponsors
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
Contacts
 

Scenery

Airbrushing
Ballast
Bridges
Buildings
Building Lighting
Grass
Hills
Inclines
Paint Conversion
Rock Faces
Hornby Skaledale
Railway Stations
Trees
Tarmac
Tunnels
Viaduct
Water
Finishing Touches
 

Electronic Projects

Railway Crossing
Building A Signal
Street Lights
 

Rolling Stock

Bachmann Wagons
Hornby Locomotives
Hornby Carriages
Hornby Wagons
Lima Locomotives
Lima Wagons
Loco Modification
Wagon Modification
 

Hornby Range Lists

Hornby Range 2006
Hornby Range 2007
Hornby Range 2008
Hornby Range 2009
Hornby Range 2010
Hornby Range 2011
Hornby Range 2012
Hornby Range 2013
Hornby Range 2014
Hornby Range 2015
Hornby Range 2016
Hornby Range 2017
Hornby Range 2018

Heljan Model Railway Locomotive Reviews -  Class 57

Author "rmg1919" (forum member)



Worth Buying - This is an average model. The model has limitations and does not have a full range of mechanical or detailing features. For a railway model to be rated as "Worth Buying" a model must score between 4 and 7. Heljan Class 57 Locomotive - First Great Western (5704) Rating 7/10

 

This was my first Heljan model and so I was slightly worried. I had no reason to be though. Aside from the odd blemish the Heljan Class 57 is an excellent model.

The most striking characteristic is the weight of the locomotive. It seems incredibly heavy - much more substantial than a Hornby, or even a Bachmann locomotive typically seems. The weight reassured me, and when I went to run the locomotive I was impressed by the smoothness of acceleration and deceleration.

 

Heljan Class 57 Locomotive - First Great Western (5704)


Details:

Model Number: 5704
Running Number: 57 604

Price Range: 37.50-83 inc VAT (Yes, rather ridiculous I know!)
Other Liveries in Range: Virgin Thunderbirds (but without 'Thunderbirds' licence)
 


Top speed at first seemed a little on the slow side, but running the model in, soon saw an improvement and it is now one of my favourite locomotives.

So, there's nothing wrong with it? Well, sadly there are a few problems.

Firstly, there is the issue that it is slightly out of proportions. The Model is, apparently, wider/fatter than it should be by something like 2mm on each side, giving a total of 4mm, which means that in real life it would be one foot wider than the real class 57. Had I not learned this through another forum I would not have noticed. I might have noticed, had I then purchased a Bachmann 57, but I am impressed enough with the model not to let this worry me. The flaw has resulted in the Heljan 47/57 range being described as "TubbyDuffs".

Secondly, the directional lighting is really rather pathetic. The mechanism definitely exists (when you take it apart you can see the bulbs and wires etc.) but the lighting seems weak and 'underpowered'. The red lights are particularly hard to see. Therefore, this is something I am in the process of fixing by replacing the bulbs with superbright LEDs (see this thread for details).

Thirdly, and this may be a one-off problem with my loco, is that the buffers are only sprung at one end. I am awaiting clarification on this issue.

Aside then from this models slight 'obesity' and rather poor lighting, the model is very good. It has a good amount of detail and the livery seems well-applied with all the various warning stickers present.

My final observation is that the locomotive retails for anywhere between 83 and 37.50. At 83 the price is too steep given the two flaws already identified. But, at the 40 mark it does seem like a bargain - and with some stockists having something of a clear-out it is now possible to pick them up for 37.50. Indeed, I was so impressed with "Pendennis Castle" (57 604) that I have subsequently ordered "Totnes Castle" (57 605).

In summary then, provided the price is right (40 or less) it really is a bargain. The detail is high, the motive power is smooth and plentiful, and with a bit of work the lighting can be easily fixed.

Furthermore, the model comes DCC ready - complete with DCC socket.
 


At a Glance


Good Points

  • Good detail

  • Good power and excellent pick-up

  • Can be found at very good prices

  • DCC ready with a socket

Bad Points

  • Directional lights very poor

  • Slightly out of proportion (4mm overall width) and so you may wish to directly compare with the Bachmann 57.

Further Observations/Other Reviews
 

Model Rail (Source: Suchampal) in their review have criticised the bogies for not being accurate. This view seems to be backed up by this post on Electric Nose.
 



Overall Recommendation

Highly Recommended - an absolute must for those modelling a 57 era and FGW geography - and best of all, it can be found at very attractive prices. The only caveat: if the thought of fixing the lighting, or of having a slightly 'obese' loco on your layout frightens you, you may be better off looking at Bachmann.

 


Resources

 

Model Photos:

Real Train with Running Number:

[back to the top]

 


Diesel Locomotive Review List

 

Heljan Model Railway Locomotive Reviews -  Class 57 Model Railway Review - Heljan Class 57 Locomotive - First Great Western (5704)


Bachmann Locomotives

Bachmann Coaches

Bachmann Wagon

Hornby Locomotives

Hornby Coaches

Hornby Wagons

Heljan Locomotives

Lima Locomotives

Lima Wagons

Locomotive Modification

Wagon Modification

 

New Modellers Shop - A Model Railway Shop - Stocking model railway wagons, coaches, carriages, electric diesel and steam locomotives, power and control equiptment, point motors, train packs, scenery, signals switches, and much much more. Supplying model products along with reviews and advice. Railway Pictures - Railway photograph gallery covering all areas of railway traction, buildings, and trackwork. Extensive photo library, which is being added to weekly. Upload and share your own images to the site using its inbuilt upload features.

Hornby Model Shop

R8312 - E-Link Computer Controlled Model Railway

Hornby E-Link
Computer Control

Price:

Hornby Model Railway Train Sets - Hornby Mixed Freight Train Set - R1126

Hornby DCC Mixed Freight Train Set

Price:

Hornby Trakmat

Hornby Model Railway Extension Track Pack A - R8221

Hornby Extension Track Pack A

Price:

Hornby Model Railway Extension Track Pack B - R8222

Hornby Extension Track Pack B

Price:

Hornby Model Railway Extension Track Pack C - R8223

Hornby Extension Track Pack C

Price:

Hornby Model Railway Extension Track Pack D - R8224

Hornby Extension Track Pack D

Price:

Hornby Model Railway Extension Track Pack E - R8225

Hornby Extension Track Pack E

Price:

Hornby Model Railway Extension Track Pack F - R8226

Hornby Extension Track Pack F

Price:

Hornby Trakmat

Model Scalextric Shop - Slot Car Shop - www.newslotcarmodellers.co.uk - F1, A1, Ralley, Road, Endurance, Touring Cars, Track, Parts, Spares
New Slot Car Modellers - A slotcar website for people new to the hobby. Supplying practical advise and information to slot car modellers and racers as they develop their hobby.
New Website Designer - New Website Designer's aim is to give basic practical advice about building your own website. The site takes you step by step through the process of picking your domain name, setting up your hosting, and building your website.