June 2015 forum competition

[Alex3410]

completed entries list updated

[Dad-1]

Sorry I've not been commenting much, but some good projects.
I've been trying to get on with other old outstanding stuff.
I will vote though ........ I'll have to go through all the builds from
the beginning !!

Geoff T.

[flying scotsman123]

Mine now as finished ad I'm going to get...

[Alex3410]

Right the final entries are in - some really impressive stuff so well done to everyone who has taken part!

if you have still not 'sent in' your finished entry please let me know and i will add you to the list but as its now the 1st its time to get voting, please review the entries and give me a list of your top 3 in order. Please PM me the list with the selected usernames only with your first choice at the top of the list.

Please also remember that voting is open to everyone on the forum and not just those who have taken part so if you can please do take the time to view the threads and vote

Voting will close at the end of the day Saturday with the results published sometime on Sunday (depending on when i get up )


right off you go


Link to index of entries that have been finished

[skyblue]

Now that I've entered would it be considered cheating/unfair if I were to update my further progress on the project on my workbench thread or should I wait until voting is over?

[Alex3410]

The hole point of the competition was to encourage people to post more about their modelling so i certainly dont want to put you off

How about you keep posting in the thread (was following with interest anyway!) but people vote on how it stands as of the 30/6 ? to keep things fair and level

[skyblue]

Thanks Alex. I will make it clear that people should based their decision on my progress before today.

[Alex3410]

just to make it clear you can vote if you have taken part as well (just no voting for yourselves )

the more votes the better

[Bufferstop]

Here's my vote for the top three in order.
1 mattmay05 -Metropolitan E-Class,
2 Carnehan -The Hornby Victorian Shops kit
3 Skyblue - pair of GWR Clerestory Coaches
Not easy to choose, it would be even harder if you asked for the order of the rest. Roll on August!
John W
aka Bufferstop

[Alex3410]

Thanks for your votes i have added them to the tally

just to make sure i dont miss any can everyone PM me their selections (dont worry Bufferstop i have yours)

[glencairn]

Many thanks to Alex for once again organising the competition. Reading every competitors build has been a pleasure. I am sure others have taken the plunge (myself included) to do some modelling.

Thanks Alex. Look forward to the next competition

Glencairn

[Alex3410]

Pleasure

its worth the trouble to see everyones entries and follow along with their progress


i have replied to everyone who has voted so far and added them all to the tally - interesting results so far

[Alex3410]

Get your votes in today!

again remember that anyone can vote so please take a moment to review the threads and PM me your top 3

[Alex3410]

Results are in!

another brilliant competition all around, thank you to everyone who put the time into entering its been fascinating following along


anyway the results are with 11 people voting :

1st - MattMay05 - 30 votes
2nd - Carnehan - 16 votes
3rd - Atso - 9 votes
4th - FS123 - 4 votes
5th - Bufferstop - 3 votes
5th - alex3410 - 3 votes
7th - skyblue - 1 vote


Well done to everyone

[carnehan]

Congratulations Mattmay05 on your worthy win. The E-Class loco was a first rate build and looks absolutely stunning.

Thank you, everyone, for my votes and giving me second place. Well chuffed.

Paul