Page 4 of 10

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Fri Feb 02, 2018 11:05 am
by Atso
Ok something completely different from me.

Image

Image

The above represents several months of on/off work. The main issues have been trying to interpret the shape of the firebox correctly and amending the source drawings, correcting errors and omissions. Ultimately the model will sit on a Farish Black Five chassis to obtain the (more or less) correct style of tender frames and a surprisingly close coupled wheelbase.

A very early test print of the model (with the original, incorrect, firebox shape) is below.

Image

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Sun Feb 04, 2018 1:59 pm
by Atso
In case anyone is interested here is the latest test print of the County....

Image

Image

...and the current state of the CAD (although the chimney needs quite a bit of work!).

Image

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Sun Feb 04, 2018 2:49 pm
by flying scotsman123
Looking very nice, I wonder if the new build County project would be interested in your work? Loco preservation groups often like to sell models of their own loco!

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Wed Feb 07, 2018 7:46 pm
by Atso
flying scotsman123 wrote:Looking very nice, I wonder if the new build County project would be interested in your work? Loco preservation groups often like to sell models of their own loco!
Thank you. I've got some issues trying to find out the correct dimensions for the BR double chimney so I might well be organising a visit to Didcot to measure the one they've got for the project! I don't know if they'll be interested in my N gauge kit effort, more likely interested in Hornby designing a new one for the 4mm scale range but it never hurts to ask! :D

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2018 10:16 am
by Atso
I woke up to a surprise today as UPS had delivered my Shapeways prints. This was a most welcome find as Shapeways predicted that they wouldn't be ready for shipping until Wednesday!

So what have I got?

Image

From left to right: MR 15' long outside frame van (this is truly tiny!), the early LNER Dia 23 fish van and the later LNER dia 134 fish van. As you can see, I've test fitted the wheels (Farish) and everything is free running.

Image

The GNR six wheel full brake. This one isn't quite as successful as the clearances aren't quite their to take the wheelsets. I think that I might be able to play with the clearances to find a better compromise to accept Farish coach wheels. At present, this coach wouldn't even take a 13mm axle as there really isn't enough clearance around the wheels. I thought this might well be the case but thought I'd try my luck anyway - three successes out of four really isn't bad. On the plus side, I'm really impressed with how well the panelling has come out.

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2018 11:40 am
by flying scotsman123
Wow! As you say, the panelling has come out nicely, shame about the wheels. I wouldn't fancy lining it out in that scale! :shock:

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2018 5:09 pm
by Atso
Thank you! Luckily, the LNER stopped lining anything that didn't have a corridor connector from 1928! :D

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Thu Feb 15, 2018 12:23 am
by mattmay05
They look the business! Really nice prints from Shapeways, always have had a mixture of results from them... some good some back... especially like the 6 wheel full brake. Really nice prints! And nice design work!

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Wed Mar 07, 2018 11:31 am
by Atso
mattmay05 wrote:They look the business! Really nice prints from Shapeways, always have had a mixture of results from them... some good some back... especially like the 6 wheel full brake. Really nice prints! And nice design work!
Thanks Matt (and sorry for the delay in replying - its been hectic over here!).

The prints still need some rubbing down but they are a massive improvement on what I used to get from Shapeways in terms of consistent quality. As per usual, where there has been the need to provide a wax support wall, the surface is rougher than where there hasn't but this cleans up nicely using some sanding sticks and other bits and pieces.

The current state of play with the fish vans is below:

Image
Image

Progress on these has been delayed due to needing them as demonstration pieces for a 'how to' article. The vans have been subjected to an application of primer, a rub down and a second squirting of primer. The cruel enlargements show that I've still got one or two bits to address but overall I'm happy with how these are turning out - especially the legible 'fish' on the door plate of the later van (remember these are N gauge!).

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Fri Mar 09, 2018 11:16 pm
by mattmay05
No problem Steve... I know what that's like, doing repairs for my local shop takes up a lot of time, especially hunting the parts...

They do look the business, amazing to think they are in N. The article sounds interesting certainly looking forward to seeing that are you allowed to say which publication?

Yes I hear you on Shapeways consistency... and quality... I was asked to re-release the Metropolitan set which I did with some changes.. I didn't want to due to them being incapable of printing them correctly... well the first one was fine... then the second one... well yes so bad I don't know how the hell that got through QC... such a shame... they have a great idea but they just haven't got the QC and the consistency to actually make me recommend them.

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Tue Apr 03, 2018 10:42 am
by Atso
DonB wrote:I've only just come across this thread, and I have to say that these are stunning. Like several other contributors, I have to keep reminding myself that these are N gauge...

Should you ever decide to upscale to 00, I'm sure I could find work for a couple of A5s...
Hi Don,

Thank you for your kind comments. If I go to 4mm, I'll keep the A5 in mind but I believe there are already a few kits on the market for this locomotive.

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Sat Apr 28, 2018 12:07 am
by Atso
The latest CAD progressing through the virtual works.

Image

Following some additional research to clear up a few fuzzy details, the County has moved forward slight too.

Image

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Tue May 01, 2018 2:44 pm
by mattmay05
Wonderful CAD work there Steve, I picked up a magazine (BRM) a couple of days ago, and there was an article of some similar looking wagons, loco's by a guy called Steve.... a know there are many people called Steve, but would I be right in assuming it could possibly be yourself?

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Tue May 01, 2018 7:50 pm
by Atso
mattmay05 wrote:Wonderful CAD work there Steve, I picked up a magazine (BRM) a couple of days ago, and there was an article of some similar looking wagons, loco's by a guy called Steve.... a know there are many people called Steve, but would I be right in assuming it could possibly be yourself?
Thanks Matt.

Re the BRM article: They're not just similar models... ;)

Re: Mainly 3D Printed LNER Locomotives in N gauge

Posted: Thu May 03, 2018 10:58 am
by mattmay05
Thought I recognised them... or there was an imposter called Steve who has exactly the same models lol A very insightful article :) great read.