Thanks for all of the compliments. OO modellers enjoying an N gauge layout: What is the world coming to?! Must be Covid madness!
I get the point about n-gaugers putting 'too much track' on the board. This was deliberately kept compact to ensure it was finishable, to experiment with some ideas and to see what I liked/didn't like before embarking on the big 'proper' layout.
It is essentially just two ovals, two passing loops and four short sidings. The amount of track is doubled in that both the front and back of the oval is in view (at least in the second revision), rather than having a lot of out-of-sight fiddle yard and a single view area.
I suppose the crux is what you want from a layout - is it to be visually ultra-realistic (great for an exhibition or club), or do you want lots to do (better for home). My first version was just two parallel tracks. Yes, it was just like most of the real railway network, but it quickly got a bit boring. Even with this current expanded configuration, this is just for watching the trains go by and still doesn't lend itself to a lot of operational interest, so I can see why some opt for the philosophy of cramming as much track in as possible.
When I have travelled on trains and looked out of the window, the exciting parts are where the train passes large expanses of track, either a station throat approach, or a goods yard / loco maintenance shed, with a 'sea of tracks' stretching out with lots of parked wagons/locos. This leaves plenty of open track but also plenty of trains to look at, so I can see the appeal of cramming lots in. It just needs to be carefully considered to keep it realistic and still look in place with its surroundings. At work also, there are lots of sidings and 'seas of wagons' which I still love to look at, but equally the real world warehouses and factory buildings are by comparison huge and completely dominate, which evens the balance, but would be difficult in n-gauge and nigh-on impossible in OO
What is perhaps surprising is how long even this simple configuration has taken - the first entry to the thread is 2012, so 8+ years in the making!
I'm going to have to think carefully what my next modelling project is going to look like as at this rate I'll need to retire before I get enough time to enjoy running trains on the next layout! I need to scale back my ambitions and consider hard what I want from a layout. Maybe I do actually have too many models which may never get taken out of their boxes?
