Page 2 of 2

Re: The Purist

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2020 11:02 am
by Bufferstop
I've looked at some first posts from newbies and chickened out of answering, usually when they are trying to create the impossible on a card table to include the Flying Scotsman set that was a present from a loved one. When they would be better off with Smokey Joe and half a dozen wagons.

Re: The Purist

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2020 11:11 am
by Bigmet
I do wonder how many of those big express passenger loco + two coaches, tiny track oval, sets, are lurking in cupboards, lofts, attics. Used a couple of times, realisation dawns that this needs something a little bigger than the dining table, put that away...

Re: The Purist

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2020 12:59 pm
by luckymucklebackit
I followed the link back to that BNS thread and his parting comment was "What I will say is that when I have finished I will post the photos and anyone will be welcomed to come and check the model. To the rest who had a little belief in me thanks for the advise." Four years on and no photos? Wonder Why?

My comment to the OP - there is a old proverb - "Those who can - do, those who can't - criticize!" I was a member of a club a good few years ago and one of the other members rarely if ever actually did anything practical - he was (still is on one of the other forums) a serial researcher, forever had his head in a book looking up some trivial fact like did DXXXX have yellow ends in the year 19XX. His most annoying trait was to watch you taking hours to put something together then say - "Its a pity you didn't........" I did eventually say to him "Its a pity you didn't actually ever build something that we could get a chance to criticize", didn't change his habits

Jim

Re: The Purist

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2020 1:13 pm
by RailwayRobbo
I'll just quote again what I heard a guy tell an exhibitor about his layout at an exibition many years ago.
"You do know that those cows weren't introduced into this country till after the period you are modelling."
The operator just gave him a smile then looked at me, shrugged his shoulders and shook his head.
I think it's called 'nit picking'.

Pete

Re: The Purist

Posted: Mon Jun 29, 2020 3:39 pm
by Byegad
You should try wargaming!

I once painted a 6mm (the height of the figure) Napoleonic French army. One 'friend' kindly pointed out that the buttons on a particular regiment's tunics,'should be in pairs' and I'd painted them singly! It finished me with the Napoleonic period.

Re: The Purist

Posted: Sun Jul 05, 2020 6:52 am
by Lancastrian
RailwayRobbo wrote:......"You do know that those cows weren't introduced into this country till after the period you are modelling."
The operator ...............
should have given him a 'pat' on the head.

Re: The Purist

Posted: Fri Jul 10, 2020 2:17 pm
by TEAMYAKIMA
I have just read this thread with interest and I do have some opinions which I won't necessarily post here, but one thing has struck me ....

I exhibit a large (26ft x10ft) Chinese HO layout (or rather I used to!) and one of the great things about Chinese HO is that very very few exhibition viewers know anything about the country or its railways and so I get very few 'opinions' from viewers.

Re: The Purist

Posted: Fri Jul 10, 2020 2:31 pm
by Bigmet
Oher than one of those who told an operator that he thought it was very interesting. :wink:

This was why Rev. Peter Denny chose to model the Great Central on his well known 'Buckingham' layout. Few then really knew much about the GCR, so the research he had done was very unlikely to be challenged and even less so criticised; leaving him free of that encumbrance! Smart fellow.

Re: The Purist

Posted: Fri Jul 10, 2020 6:45 pm
by TEAMYAKIMA
Bigmet wrote:

This was why Rev. Peter Denny chose to model the Great Central on his well known 'Buckingham' layout. Few then really knew much about the GCR, so the research he had done was very unlikely to be challenged and even less so criticised; leaving him free of that encumbrance! Smart fellow.


If you're saying that I have something in common with the Rev. Peter Denny, I'll take that! :D

Re: The Purist

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 12:01 am
by George Stein
Naturally it helps to be in the USA modelling the Great Western. No one has called me out for using five wires instead of six on my line side fencing.

George
North Catolina

Re: The Purist

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 1:08 am
by Chuffed
Whilst looking for a decent site to join I came across a site for EM, somewhere in Yorkshire I recall. They said they accepted newbies and had a 00 layout for them to play trains before progressing. Suffice to say I enjoy playing trains even if it is code 100 and the stock isn't close coupled :D

Re: The Purist

Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2020 9:00 am
by Bigmet
George Stein wrote:Naturally it helps to be in the USA modelling the Great Western. No one has called me out for using five wires instead of six on my line side fencing...

Ever made the trip to Golden Railroad Museum, Colorado? Got a lovely old 1880's wooden clerestory coach branded 'Great Western' there.

(And there was no trouble getting inside the firebox of their CB&Q O5 4-8-4 either, US museum staff being a lot more relaxed than our uptight NRM crew...)

Re: The Purist

Posted: Thu Jul 16, 2020 12:35 am
by DonB
That is why I have modelled a "what if" - It is unlikely I'll ever get some rivet counter saying "Loco xxxx never ran on the GCR..." Only silly comments like "the points in your fiddle yard are too sharp," or "your building that you built from actual drawings looks wrong..."

I have just revisited that BNS thread; I've been feeling unwell today, and needed a good old chuckle.

George Stein wrote:...No one has called me out for using five wires instead of six on my line side fencing.


You did WHAT??! :lol: :lol: